Scientific publishing guide
How to Respond to Peer Reviewers: A Practical Guide
You’ve spent months, perhaps years, designing a study, collecting data, analysing the results and preparing a scientific manuscript. You submit it to a journal, and eventually the reviewers’ reports arrive.
Reviewer 1 has some useful suggestions. Reviewer 2 appears to have read an entirely different manuscript. Reviewer 3 would like you to repeat the entire experiment, preferably with a larger sample, an additional intervention and approximately six more years of funding. And Reviewer 4? Well, Reviewer 4 hates you, your research, and apparently every life decision you’ve ever made.
Welcome to peer review.
Fortunately, reviewers are rarely quite this theatrical. Constructive reviews can identify weaknesses, expose unclear explanations and substantially improve scientific papers. But peer review also involves professional judgement, which can be subjective, inconsistent and occasionally wrong. The research literature has documented variation between reviewers’ assessments; a report is expert advice, not an infallible measurement of manuscript quality.11
There is no strict formula for responding to peer reviewers. The appropriate response depends on the scientific merit of the concern, your research objectives, the editor’s priorities and what the evidence can support. It also requires something researchers don’t always associate with journal correspondence: emotional intelligence.
This guide explains how to evaluate reviewer comments, manage frustration, write a point-by-point response letter, defend sound scientific decisions and revise your manuscript without compromising the research.
Table of contents
- Develop the research question
- Plan the study
- Prepare and conduct the study
- Collect and manage data
- Analyse and interpret
- Write, submit and publish
Peer-review revisions belong to the final stage, but may require revisiting methods, analyses and interpretation from earlier stages.
1. Peer review is a conversation, not an instruction manual
Peer review helps journal editors evaluate the quality, importance and suitability of submitted research. Reviewers examine a manuscript and comment on its design, methods, analyses, interpretation, reporting or contribution to the literature. At its best, the process strengthens the eventual publication.12
Reviewers differ in expertise, methodological preferences and expectations. Some comments identify demonstrable problems: an incorrectly described intervention, inconsistent sample sizes, an unsuitable analysis or a conclusion that exceeds the evidence. Others are more subjective: whether the Introduction is too long, whether an interpretation is persuasive or whether the study is sufficiently novel.
Occasionally a reviewer recommends something scientifically inappropriate. The existence of a reviewer comment doesn’t automatically make it correct. Equally, finding the comment irritating doesn’t make it wrong.
The Reviewer 2 phenomenon
Reviewer 2 has become something of an academic celebrity, despite usually remaining anonymous. The memes capture a recognisable experience: a report can seem unnecessarily harsh or almost entirely disconnected from the paper being reviewed.
Humour helps put the frustration in perspective. But a meme cannot determine whether the criticism is justified. A demanding reviewer may identify the manuscript’s most important weakness; a friendly reviewer may overlook it. Evaluate what the report says, not merely how it makes you feel.
Authors remain responsible for the science
Reviewers make recommendations; the handling editor evaluates them and makes the journal’s editorial decision. Authors retain responsibility for the accuracy and integrity of their research.10
Responding well therefore means more than accepting every suggestion. It means understanding each concern, correcting genuine weaknesses and explaining decisions that warrant clarification or disagreement.
2. Before responding: manage your reaction
Receiving criticism of work you’ve spent years developing can be uncomfortable. Perhaps a reviewer questions a technique you’ve used throughout your career. Perhaps another dismisses the significance of a study that required years of recruitment and laboratory work.
Disappointment, defensiveness and frustration are understandable. But your first emotional reaction is not necessarily your best scientific judgement.
Sleep on it. Go for a walk.
Read the editor’s letter and the review reports, noting any urgent deadlines. Then—unless a genuine time constraint prevents it—step away before writing the formal response.
Sleep on it. Go for a walk. Get away from the computer and stop rereading the offending sentence for the seventeenth time.
On returning, you may find that the criticism has merit. Or you may still disagree, but be better able to explain why. The aim isn’t to suppress frustration; it’s to stop frustration from making the scientific decision.
Ask an independent colleague
Discuss difficult comments with a trusted colleague who wasn’t an author on the paper. Someone with relevant expertise but less personal investment may spot a real weakness, an incorrect reviewer assumption or a mismatch between the question and the requested analysis.
Ask for an independent assessment, not merely confirmation that Reviewer 2 is a menace to civilisation. Respect confidentiality: check journal requirements before sharing manuscripts or reviewer reports outside the author team, and obtain permission where needed. If sharing is restricted, discuss the general methodological question without disclosing confidential content.
Separate the comment from your interpretation
Consider: “The statistical approach is inadequately justified.” Your immediate interpretation might be: “This person thinks I don’t understand statistics.”
But the reviewer may simply want a clearer description of the model, assumptions or rationale. Respond to the concern expressed, not to the judgement you’ve imagined behind it. This is a practical application of emotional intelligence: recognising an emotional reaction without allowing it to dictate your communication.
Focus on what you can control
You can’t control reviewers’ expertise, competing methodological preferences or the final editorial decision. You can control the care with which you assess criticism, the quality of revisions and the professionalism of your reply. Those are useful places to invest your energy.
3. Understand the editor’s decision and priorities
Before working through individual comments, read the editor’s decision letter carefully. It may identify the major obstacles to publication, distinguish essential changes from optional suggestions or specify additional analyses.
Minor revision, major revision or rejection?
Journals use different categories, including minor revision, major revision, revise and resubmit, and rejection. Their precise meaning varies between journals. An invitation to revise is not a guarantee of acceptance; a major revision is not necessarily a verdict that the science is fundamentally flawed.
Read the specific editorial instructions rather than relying on the label.
Identify essential concerns
A reviewer may suggest a new experiment because it would be interesting. The editor may or may not regard it as necessary. Distinguish concerns that challenge the paper’s central claims from suggestions that would extend the scope of the research.
If a substantial request is ambiguous, contact the handling editor for clarification before committing major resources. Check the deadline and whether the journal requires a marked-up manuscript, clean version, cover letter or separate response document.89
4. Read and classify every reviewer comment
Collect all editor and reviewer comments in a working document, keeping the original wording. Break compound comments into separate actionable concerns.
For example, “The Methods lack intervention detail, the analysis is insufficiently justified and the conclusions are overstated” contains three distinct issues.
Classify the concerns
The table below shows some common reviewer concerns and possible responses:
| Concern | Example | Response strategy |
|---|---|---|
| Methods | Intervention details unclear | Add reproducible methodological detail |
| Statistics | Primary comparison questioned | Evaluate the criticism; correct, justify or clarify the analysis |
| Reporting | Sample numbers conflict | Reconcile the manuscript and tables |
| Interpretation | Claims exceed evidence | Qualify conclusions and related abstract claims |
| Literature | Relevant studies omitted | Assess and cite pertinent evidence |
| Presentation | Figure or paragraph confusing | Improve clarity and navigation |
| Scope or preference | Additional experiment suggested | Assess necessity, value and feasibility |
This is a practical organisational framework, not a formal scientific scoring system.
Find the concern beneath the proposed solution
Sometimes a reviewer identifies a genuine problem but recommends the wrong remedy. A trial’s treatment-effect analysis may be confusing, yet separate within-group tests may not answer the between-group research question. The underlying concern is clarity about the estimated treatment effect, not necessarily a need to change the test.
Similarly, a request for numerous additional citations may signal a weak rationale. That doesn’t mean every suggested paper belongs in the Introduction.
Prioritise validity over presentation
Address the research question, design, primary analysis and conclusions before minor language changes. Then handle the presentation comments too: sound science that’s difficult to understand is difficult to assess.
5. Plan the manuscript revision before writing the response letter
Develop a coordinated revision plan before polishing individual responses. A changed analysis may affect the Methods, Results, tables, abstract and Discussion; an isolated edit can easily create inconsistencies elsewhere.
Work with your coauthors
Assign additional analyses, literature checks, methodological clarifications and writing revisions to people with relevant responsibility and expertise. Maintain a shared record of actions and unresolved decisions. Substantive scientific revisions should be discussed with the appropriate authors rather than made for the sole purpose of completing the rebuttal letter.
Resolve major scientific concerns first
Don’t spend hours polishing a conclusion that may change after a requested reanalysis. Assess the most consequential criticisms before making cosmetic edits.
Is the additional work justified?
Evaluate suggested experiments and analyses according to the study’s aims, available evidence, feasibility and claims. A well-chosen sensitivity analysis may strengthen the paper; an unplanned subgroup analysis may generate more confusion than insight. If an unresolvable limitation means a claim cannot be supported, narrow the claim rather than pretending the limitation disappeared.
6. How to write a point-by-point response letter
A response letter should make it easy for editors and reviewers to see what the authors considered, what changed and why. There’s no universally mandatory layout. Some journals prefer full revised passages in the letter; others favour concise explanations with precise locations. Follow the journal’s instructions.389
Begin with a concise overview
Briefly acknowledge the reviews and summarise the major changes:
We thank the editor and reviewers for assessing our manuscript. We have clarified the primary analysis, added effect estimates and confidence intervals to the Results, and revised the Discussion to distinguish the findings from their clinical implications. We address each comment below and identify the corresponding changes in the manuscript.
An enthusiastic paragraph praising every comment as exceptionally insightful isn’t necessary.
Use a consistent structure
A practical sequence is reviewer comment → authors’ scientific assessment → action taken → manuscript location. Reproduce comments or identify them unambiguously, address separate issues individually, and use exact page/line references from the final revised document. Clear formatting helps readers distinguish comments from responses.
The prominent example above illustrates a legitimate disagreement: the authors don’t change a defensible primary analysis simply to satisfy a reviewer’s preferred test. They also improve the manuscript’s explanation. Prespecification is not enough on its own—the original analysis must actually be appropriate for the objective and design.
Two other useful response types
Accepting a genuine omission. Reviewer: “The eligibility criteria are insufficiently described.” Response: “We agree that the original description lacked necessary detail. We have expanded the Methods to specify the age range, diagnostic criteria and principal exclusions (page X, lines XX–XX).”
Clarifying an existing procedure. Reviewer: “When was blood pressure assessed relative to the final exercise session?” Response: “We appreciate that the timing was unclear. Blood pressure was assessed 48 hours after the final supervised session. We have clarified the schedule in the Methods (page X, lines XX–XX).”
The second response accepts a communication problem without pretending the original study procedure was different.
Show what changed
Avoid saying only “This is already explained in the Methods.” Explain whether the manuscript was changed, where the change appears and why it resolves the concern. If no change was warranted, explain the rationale. Cross-reference overlapping replies rather than pasting lengthy passages repeatedly.
7. How to disagree with a reviewer respectfully
Disagreement can be scientifically responsible. The distinction is between rejecting a comment because it feels offensive and declining a change because it would be incorrect, misleading or irrelevant to the stated question.
Defend the decision, not your reputation
Describe the relevant design, comparison, method or measurement and explain why it fits the research objective. Cite credible methodological or validation evidence where appropriate. Avoid attacking the reviewer’s expertise.
“Everyone knows Method X is the gold standard” isn’t enough. Even an established method may have important assumptions or be misapplied.
Disagreement may still reveal a writing problem
A reviewer can misunderstand a scientifically valid analysis because the manuscript is unclear. You may retain the analysis and improve the explanation. The goal is not to prove that the reviewer should have understood the original text; it’s to make the paper easier for future readers to evaluate.
8. Handling unreasonable, conflicting or inappropriate comments
Some requests cannot be followed as written. Assess whether the problem is scientific, editorial, practical or professional, and respond proportionately.
An impossible follow-up experiment
A reviewer asks authors of a completed 12-week exercise trial for another year of follow-up. Long-term effectiveness may be an important question, but the data don’t exist and the original study was designed around a 12-week outcome.
A response could say: “We agree that longer-term follow-up would help establish the durability of the intervention effect. These data are unavailable because the study was designed to assess the 12-week outcome. We have revised the Discussion to clarify that our findings cannot establish longer-term effectiveness and identified this as a question for future work.”
If the paper currently claims long-term benefit, that claim must be corrected. Infeasibility isn’t an excuse for unsupported conclusions.
Contradictory reviewers
Reviewer 1 wants the Introduction shortened; Reviewer 2 asks for more background. Perhaps both are pointing towards a more focused Introduction: remove general material, strengthen evidence directly related to the knowledge gap. If requests genuinely conflict and cannot be reconciled, explain the alternatives to the editor and ask for guidance.
Irrelevant citations or inappropriate criticism
Evaluate suggested references on relevance and evidential value, including literature that challenges your interpretation. Don’t assume the reviewer has an ulterior motive. If citation requests seem coercive or a review contains personal attacks, discriminatory statements or other unprofessional material, use the journal’s editorial procedures rather than retaliating.
9. Responding to methodological and statistical criticism
Statistical comments deserve particular care because they may change the numerical results or the conclusions. Evaluate the scientific concern first, then determine whether the existing approach is valid, requires clarification or needs correction.
Sample size and observed power
A reviewer may question the sample size or request a post hoc observed-power calculation. Examine the actual issue: was the prospective sample-size rationale credible, and are the estimates sufficiently precise for the study’s claims? Observed power calculated from the observed effect typically provides little useful additional information about a completed study. Discuss effect estimates, confidence intervals and limitations instead; revise claims that the evidence cannot support.
Requests for different analyses
For a randomised trial, within-group paired tests don’t replace an appropriate between-group treatment comparison. For repeated measurements, the analysis must respect within-person dependence. In observational work, a criticism of the adjustment strategy may highlight a real risk of confounding.
If a method is wrong, correct it and explain what changed. If the original analysis is valid but an alternative is scientifically informative, consider a clearly labelled sensitivity analysis. Don’t run a series of tests simply to find the most agreeable P value.
Missing data and clinical interpretation
Clarify the amount and handling of missing data, the analysis population and the assumptions behind the approach. Consider sensitivity analyses when conclusions depend on uncertain assumptions.
If the reviewer challenges an exaggerated clinical claim, examine effect magnitude, uncertainty, patient relevance and supporting evidence. Revising the interpretation is usually more helpful than defending the P value.
For more methodological detail, see How to Report Statistical Results, How to Write a Statistical Analysis Plan and How to Choose the Right Statistical Test.
10. Responding to criticism of novelty, interpretation and writing
Some of the most valuable comments concern how the research is communicated rather than which analysis was run.
Overstated conclusions
If a reviewer identifies unsupported causal language, exaggerated clinical implications or claims beyond the follow-up period, check the point carefully. Correct it throughout the Results interpretation, Discussion, abstract and conclusion. A short intervention trial doesn’t establish permanent benefit; an observational association doesn’t automatically establish causation.
Novelty and the value of replication
Research can contribute through rigorous replication, improved precision, stronger designs or new populations. Defend a genuine contribution accurately; don’t claim novelty merely because no other paper examined precisely this combination of variables on a Tuesday.
Confusing writing and excessive gratitude
If the reviewer can’t identify the primary outcome, the Methods may need restructuring even if the answer is technically present. Good reporting makes critical details discoverable. Likewise, the response letter needs clear reasoning rather than an extended series of ceremonial thank-yous.
For broader manuscript-writing support, see How to Write a Scientific Manuscript for Publication. Blazon Scientific also provides scientific manuscript editing, methodological review and statistical analysis services.
11. Final checks before resubmission
Read the response letter alongside the revised manuscript. If the letter says that a method was clarified, check the paragraph. If a new sensitivity analysis was performed, verify the values and the interpretation. If a limitation was acknowledged, ensure the abstract hasn’t retained the original overstatement.
Reconcile scientific changes
New analyses may alter estimates, intervals, participant counts or conclusions. Check the Methods, Results, tables, figures, abstract, Discussion and supplements for consistency. Page and line numbers in the response must match the actual resubmission files.
Confirm coauthor approval and journal requirements
Obtain the appropriate coauthor review and approval of substantive changes. Follow the journal’s requirements for clean and tracked-change manuscripts, supplementary documents, cover letters and reviewer-facing or editor-only correspondence.
Finally, read the response for tone. A sentence drafted during an irritated afternoon may look quite different the next morning.
12. Final response-to-reviewers checklist
Use this as a final review, not a substitute for scientific judgement.
- I’ve read the editor’s decision and identified its priorities.
- I’ve given myself time before responding to difficult criticism.
- I’ve sought independent advice where useful, respecting confidentiality.
- Every substantive reviewer and editor comment has been addressed.
- I’ve distinguished underlying concerns from proposed remedies.
- Genuine methodological, numerical and reporting errors have been corrected.
- Additional analyses or experiments were assessed for scientific merit and feasibility.
- Disagreements are respectful, specific and supported by reasoning or evidence.
- Conflicting requests have been reconciled or discussed with the editor.
- Each response states what changed, what was clarified or why no change was made.
- The response’s page and line references are accurate.
- Analyses, numbers and interpretations agree throughout the revised paper.
- Relevant coauthors have reviewed and approved substantive revisions.
- The resubmission meets the journal’s current instructions.
- I’ve removed unnecessary defensiveness, sarcasm and personal criticism.
The objective isn’t to persuade every reviewer that the authors were right all along. It’s to demonstrate that concerns were evaluated, the work was improved where necessary and the remaining scientific decisions are defensible.
And if Reviewer 4 still hates all your life decisions, at least the response letter won’t give them another one to complain about.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to agree with every peer reviewer comment?
No. Consider every substantive concern, correct genuine weaknesses and respectfully justify any decision not to follow a suggestion. The editor’s instructions and the scientific validity of the work remain important.
What should I do if a reviewer is wrong?
Check whether the comment is actually mistaken or instead exposes unclear writing. Explain the relevant evidence or methodology, and clarify the manuscript if future readers might have the same difficulty.
What if two reviewers request contradictory changes?
Look beneath both requests. A focused revision may address their underlying concerns even when their suggested actions differ. If the requests genuinely conflict, seek guidance from the handling editor.
Can I decline requests for additional experiments or analyses?
Yes, when the work is inappropriate, beyond the study’s scope or infeasible. Explain the reasons and address any valid limitation. Declining additional work does not justify retaining an unsupported central claim.
How long should a response-to-reviewers letter be?
Long enough to answer all substantive points clearly, but concise enough to navigate. Follow journal requirements, distinguish comments from responses and identify the exact location of changes.
References and further reading
- Dirks-Naylor AJ. A primer: how to address peer reviews of your manuscript. Advances in Physiology Education. 2024;48(1):103–104. https://doi.org/10.1152/advan.00250.2023.
- Seals DR. Publishing particulars: Part 3. General writing tips, editing, and responding to peer review. American Journal of Physiology-Regulatory, Integrative and Comparative Physiology. 2023;324(3):R409–R424. https://doi.org/10.1152/ajpregu.00270.2022.
- Ehrman JK. Responding to a Manuscript Reviewer: Respectful, Pointed, and Complete. Journal of Clinical Exercise Physiology. 2025;13(4):111–112. https://jcep.kglmeridian.com/downloadpdf/view/journals/ceph/13/4/article-p111-s.pdf.
- Cushman M. How I respond to peer reviewer comments. Research and Practice in Thrombosis and Haemostasis. 2023;7(2):100120. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rpth.2023.100120.
- Oldham MA, Kontos N, Baller E, Cerimele JM. JACLP guide for manuscript peer review: how to perform a peer review and how to be responsive to reviewer comments. Journal of the Academy of Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry. 2023;64(5):468–472. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaclp.2023.01.011.
- Noble WS. Ten simple rules for writing a response to reviewers. PLoS Computational Biology. 2017;13(10):e1005730. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1005730.
- Bahadoran Z, Mirmiran P, Kashfi K, Ghasemi A. Scientific publishing in biomedicine: revising a peer-reviewed manuscript. International Journal of Endocrinology and Metabolism. 2022;20(1):e120366. https://doi.org/10.5812/ijem.120366.
- How to respond to reviewers. Editorial. Nature Computational Science. 2025. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43588-025-00931-5.
- How to write a rebuttal letter. Editorial. Nature Methods. 2026;23:1919. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41592-026-03261-0.
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Responsibilities in the submission and peer-review process. ICMJE Recommendations. Accessed 19 November 2026. https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/browse/roles-and-responsibilities/responsibilities-in-the-submission-and-peer-peview-process.html.
- Onitilo AA, Engel JM, Salzman-Scott SA, Stankowski RV, Doi SAR. Reliability of reviewer ratings in the manuscript peer review process: an opportunity for improvement. Accountability in Research. 2013;20(4):270–284. https://doi.org/10.1080/08989621.2013.804345.
